Tamara Alexander, Shelley Gray, Dorothy Love, and Elizabeth Musser. Among the Fair Magnolias: Four Southern Love Stories. Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson, 2015.
Sometimes I find new books by tracking my favorite authors or series of books. Other times, I simply fall in love with a book’s cover and can’t wait to read it. For authors Tamara Alexander, Shelley Gray, Dorothy Love, and Elizabeth Musser, their latest compilation of novellas in Among the Fair Magnolias has all of the above, making it a must read this month!
Among the Fair Magnolias brings together some of Christian fiction’s great authors, who contribute stories that depict the American South during the period around the Civil War. Through four diverse love stories, they bring the period to life and show the undeterred nature of America’s women in the face of some of life’s greatest challenges.
Ms. Love’s “Heart So True” tells the story of Abigail Clayton as she faces the choice between following her father’s wishes for a spouse or finally marrying the man who has captured her heart. With a pleasant storyline and a wonderful sense of place, “Heart So True” builds on characters introduced in Carolina Gold, while highlighting Ms. Love’s storytelling ability in what is certainly my favorite piece so far by this author.
“To Mend a Dream” by Ms. Alexander continues the story of a secondary character first introduced in To Win Her Favor. Susannah Darby lost her family’s home after the Civil War and finds herself having to redecorate the house as part of a commission for her work as a seamstress. When Northerner Aidan Bedford encounters Susannah admiring his newly-acquired land, his view of the future suddenly changes. “To Mend a Dream” is a sweet and poignant story that showcases Ms. Alexander’s flair for characters and historical detail.
Ms. Musser’s “Love Beyond Limits” offers a surprising, but well-placed, addition to Among the Fair Magnolias. Having grown up on her father’s plantation, Emily Derracott pushes cultural norms in the South with her insistence on educating her family’s former slaves. When her father insists that she marry a long-time neighbor, Emily must choose between her politics and social convention in a reconstructed South. Ms. Musser builds upon historical themes and characters similar to those found in Ms. Alexander’s novels. However, this story contained several historical details that did not necessarily fit with the period.
Lastly, “An Outlaw’s Heart” by Ms. Gray takes readers to post-Civil War Texas, where the effects of the war continue to touch the lives of one small town. Russell Champion returns to his hometown after spending the last seven years running from his past. When he finally revisits his mother and the girl he left behind, Russell must choose between leaving again or finding a new life with those he loves. Through the use of a different writing style, Ms. Gray’s story offers the greatest deviation from the rest of the collection. However, the ultimate themes of renewal, choices, and overcoming obstacles tie this story to the rest of the book.
Overall, I was quite thrilled with Among the Fair Magnolias. Fans who enjoy any of the authors’ novels and other stories will definitely appreciate the book, as it offers many connections with characters, settings, and storylines first depicted in the authors’ other works. Additionally, those readers who enjoy Southern-inspired Christian fiction will also appreciate the compilation. In general, I thought the stories fit fairly well together. The book reminded me of compilations of L.M. Montgomery’s wonderfully sweet and inspiring short story collections, with a slight change in geography. At several points, the stories in Among the Fair Magnolias shared similar themes and premises to examples of Ms. Montgomery’s work, which I found to be absolutely delightful.
Special thanks to BookLook Bloggers for the advanced copy of Among the Fair Magnolias!
Looking for this book? Support the Books and Biscuits blog, while shopping at:
Amazon – Among the Fair Magnolias: Four Southern Love Stories
Christianbook.com – Among the Fair Magnolias: Four Southern Love Stories